Introduction. Many
students enter the MLIS program with undergraduate or
graduate backgrounds that include a strong orientation
to research and writing. Other
students perhaps have had different experiences or have
been out of school for a considerable period of time. Whatever
is the case, students will be expected to do considerable
research and many writing projects as part of their time
in the School. My intent here is to provide some
recommendations for some basic tools and guides that
might help them in their assignments here. These
are personal recommendations, and students should be
prepared to follow recommendations from other faculty
for particular courses. Since the library, archives,
and information professions publish many different kinds
of journals, practice manuals, and research monographs,
there are a variety of style manuals and other basic
research and writing tools that are appropriate for MLIS
students.
What I have described below are print publications. Students
may find a variety of research and writing tools online,
but my personal preference is for a bookshelf of printed
references. While I may go into the online version
of the Oxford English Dictionary to investigate a word’s
meaning and origins, mostly I find it is more convenient
to pull off a bound volume and use its index or table
of contents to answer a question, check out a grammatical
rule, or confirm my suspicion about how to cite a source. Students
need to discover, and perhaps some may have already in
a previous education program or workplace, what works
best for them to prepare written assignments in this
program. Faculty members are here to advise them,
and students should take advantage of their availability
to answer questions about appropriate research and writing
tools. What students learn here will be useful
for them in their subsequent professional careers.
Style Manuals. Students need to follow specific
course requirements for the use of a style manual, and
students will find that there is a variety of such manuals
used by different faculty members. Some students
also will enter the program having experience with a
particular style manual. Students should plan on
acquiring the various manuals recommended to them, since
they will find them extremely useful in their future
careers, whether for writing internal reports or preparing
public documents. The fifteenth edition of the
Chicago Manual of Style (Chicago: University of Chicago
Press, 2003) continues a tradition dating back to 1906,
and this style manual is one of the most frequently recommended. Students
will find in it advice about how to cite books, articles,
newsletters, newspapers, Web sites and other electronic
sources, grey literature, government documents, and a
host of other sources. There is also advice in
using numbers and mathematical formulas, following copyright
restrictions, writing with clarity, and grammar and usage. Students
won’t make a mistake in acquiring a copy of this
manual.
The University of Chicago is probably the leading publisher
of advice guides for academic writing. For example,
Jane E. Miller, The Chicago Guide to Writing About Numbers
(Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2004) is a basic
reference on using statistics in academic essays. As
the author argues, “Writing about numbers is a
complex process: it involves finding pertinent numbers,
identifying patterns, calculating comparisons, organizing
ideas, designing tables or charts, and finally, writing
prose. . . . This book integrates all of these
facets into one volume, pointing out how each aspect
of the process affects the others. . . “ The
book is divided into sections focusing on principles,
tools, and “putting it all altogether,” and
it is an excellent guide to integrating quantitative
material into any aspect of writing. Or, as another
example, Jacques Barzun, Simple & Direct: A Rhetoric
for Writers, rev. ed. (Chicago: University of Chicago
Press, 1985) provides excellent advice about matters
like diction, linking words, tone, meaning, composition,
and revising. Barzun notes that “Rhetoric
is the craft of setting down words and marks right; or
again: Rhetoric shows you how to put words together so
that the reader not simply may but must grasp your meaning.” Barzun’s
title gets to the heart of his message: “The whole
world will tell you, if you care to ask, that your words
should be simple & direct.” Such guides
can help a student rethink their approach to writing,
and since writing is a skill learned by considerable
practice, and, as well, lots of failures, any sources
helping one re-evaluate his or her approach to writing
will be beneficial. And, other than the full Chicago
Manual of Style, students might find Kate Turabian’s
A Manual for Writers of Term Papers, Theses, and Dissertations,
6th rev. ed. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1996),
a shorthand version of the manual, the most useful style
reference available to them.
Dictionaries. Students should have a good dictionary,
such as the American Heritage Dictionary of the English
Language (New York: Houghton Mifflin, 2000) or the Merriam-Webster’s
Collegiate Dictionary (Springfield, MA: Merriam-Webster,
Inc., 1998). Students will have access to dictionaries
online, but they are just as handy to pull off a shelf
close to one’s writing table (and print versions
are sometimes easier to use). Dictionaries are
more than dictionaries these days, including abbreviations
and symbols, foreign words and phrases, biographical
and historical information, atlases, synonyms, advice
on usage, word histories, style guides, and other helpful
tools. No matter how advanced a writer a student
(or faculty member) might think they are, there always
will be an occasion when it will be helpful to have quick
access to a dictionary for a last minute check or revision.
Thesaurus. The student, facing
piles of notes (real or virtual) and attempting to craft
a coherent essay, will sooner or later face the situation
when they need a different word for “book” or
something other than “read.” A thesaurus,
coming from the Latin or Greek word for “treasury,” is
the needed tool. Bartlett's Roget's Thesaurus
(Boston: Little, Brown, 1996) is as good a thesaurus
as one needs, providing ample synonyms grouped by concept
and alphabetical, with a detailed index. Most word
processing software packages now include a thesaurus,
but these, even while useful, are not as complete as
the published versions. Students will find a thesaurus
an oft-used reference.
Grammar. Brief introductions to good or accurate
grammar can be found in dictionaries and other such basic
references. The classic volume dedicated to this, one
that is so established that it has been parodied, is
William Strunk, Jr., E.B. White, and Roger Angell, The
Elements of Style, 4th. ed. (New York: Longman, 2000),
generally just referred to as “Strunk and White.” It
provides a straightforward examination of English style,
emphasizing usage rules and composition principles most
often compromised. Anyone reading this volume comes
away with improvements to their writing, and it deserves
a prominent place on the personal reference shelf. It
is also compact enough to be carried about in one’s
briefcase or purse, for a quick reference or to kill
a few minutes waiting to board the airplane; a few minutes
with Strunk and White is never a waste of time.
Essay Writing. Students in the MLIS program will
be asked to write a lot of essays, from the research
paper to the personal reflection. There are a lot
of interesting aids to those needing to write an essay,
but I will mention just two examples (students, coming
from a wide variety of backgrounds, will need to find
one that is most suitable to their background and experience
levels). Frank L. Cioffi, The Imaginative Argument:
A Practical Manifesto for Writers (Princeton: Princeton
University Press, 2005) offers a “manifesto for
the protection, for the nurturance, of this endangered
species” – the “written argument,
which logically explains and defends a controversial
idea.” Cioffi, who has taught writing at the college
level, describes the process of writing essays, identifying
and targeting audiences, planning the writing project,
developing a thesis for the essay or monograph, being
creative in the research paper or essay, and the importance
of style. This is an excellent primer for graduate
students because its focus is the “academic argument,” the
prevalent form of nonfiction writing at any university.
Scott F. Crider, The Office of Assertion: An Art of Rhetoric
for the Academic Essay (Wilmington, Del.: ISI Books,
2005) is a text written for the first-year college student,
providing useful advice for anyone writing an academic
essay. Crider discusses the rhetorical nature of
the essay, the composing of a thesis, the use and citing
of evidence, the structure of the essay, and the importance
of style.
Writing as Art and Science. While it appears that
there are considerable differences between professional,
scholarly, and creative writing, most acknowledge that
there are universal principles underlying good writing. There
are lots of interesting analyses of the craft of writing
that might assist students to understand the challenges
and hard work facing them in writing anything, whether
a memorandum or an essay for publication. Anne Lamott,
Bird by Bird: Some Instructions on Writing and Life (New
York: Anchor Books, 1994) is the classic, inspirational
guide for those thinking of trying writing or who are
looking for advice about it. In a witty and lively
fashion, the author discusses all facets of writing,
from planning a project to dealing with multiple rejections
of finished pieces. Lamott provides a lot of excellent
advice about the practical aspects of writing, including
having others read drafts to working with editors and
publishers. Joyce Carol Oates, The Faith of a
Writer: Life, Craft, Art (New York: HarperCollins, 2003)
provides personal thoughts on the art of writing by one
of America’s most prolific and important writers. Oates
discourses on the act of writing, the relationship between
reading and writing, life experiences and writing, the
nature of writing and receiving criticism, and the forces
compelling one to write. Richard Rhodes, How to
Write: Advice and Reflections (New York: HarperCollins
Publishers, 1995) is an excellent peek into the fact
that writing fiction and non-fiction is often not as
different as one might think. Rhodes won a number
of awards, including the Pulitzer Prize, for his book
on the atomic bomb (The Making of the Atom Bomb). He
connects reading with writing, reviews the tools necessary
for writing, the use of different voices and styles for
different kinds of writing, planning and organizing writing,
the nature of editing, finding support for freelance
writing, and what other writers have had to say about
the nature of writing.
Reading and the Art of Writing. Jacques Barzun,
like many academics and professional writers, reminds
us that writing really can’t be taught but that
writers must teach themselves. Nearly everyone
who has discoursed on writing indicates that writers
develop their talents by being readers. For students
preparing to be information professionals, following
such advice certainly means reading deeply and broadly
into the professional and scholarly literature supporting
library, archives, and information management and sciences. Learning
to write clearly and cogently also means reading good
writers and imitating their styles. Ben Yagoda,
The Sound on the Page: Style and Voice in Writing (New
York: HarperCollins, 2004), for example, compares writing
styles to fingerprints in their distinctiveness. Yagoda
provides a volume of advice about developing and mimicking
writing styles. This journalism professor helps
in teaching a writer not only the rudiments of style,
but he considers how styles need to change and adapt
from one’s beginning stages to their more developed
and mature writing phases. Graduate students and
scholars need to go through a similar process, learning
the styles of their field and the journals they publish
in.
Students are advised to identify and read good writers
in areas of interest to them, with the idea that their
own writing might improve. For me, some of my favorite
writers are the architectural critic and historian Witold
Rybzinski, engineer and social commentator Henry Petroski,
and the late communications theorist Neil Postman. While
I cannot claim to write as well as any of them, and this
essay ought to be evidence enough, I know that assiduously
reading them cannot but have helped my own writing style
and effectiveness.
Every writer commenting on their craft usually devotes
considerable attention to the influence of reading on
their work. Indeed, there is certainly something
close to universal consensus that one cannot be a good
writer or scholar if they are not a committed and astute
reader. The range of writing about reading and
its connection to scholarship and writing is quite diverse. There
are some interesting compilations of essays by writers
on the act and importance of reading. J. Peder
Zane, ed., Remarkable Reads: 34 Writers and Their Adventures
in Reading (New York: W. W. Norton and Co., 2004) is
a collection of essays where writers describe one book
important to their lives and vocation.
Many writers have written memoirs about and commentaries
on their work and any number of these can be consulted
by the graduate student or beginning scholar or professional.
Fiction and creative writers are generally most useful
for comments on style, creativity, the task of writing,
working with agents, getting published, and other aspects
of the writing life. A convenient compilation of
writers discussing the act of writing and publishing,
Marie Arana, ed., The Writing Life: Writers on How They
Think and Work: A Collection from the Washington Post
Book World (New York: Public Affairs, 2003), featuring
the reflections of many prominent writers such as Joyce
Carol Oates, James Michener, David McCullough, Michael
Korda, Reynolds Price, and Tracy Kidder, is a good place
to start for students looking for a writer of their own
to follow and emulate. These essays are arranged
thematically, including becoming a writer, the raw material
that goes into writing, the act of writing (“hunkering
down”), translating and reuse of old material,
researching and writing nonfiction, and evaluating finished,
published work. There are also many other useful compilations
of essays on writing, offering in a single volume a multiplicity
of views on the craft. Kevin Smokler, ed., Bookmark
Now: Writing in Unreaderly Times (New York: Basic Books,
2005), collects a group who have become successful writers
in the last decade or so of the 20th century and who
relate their writing to their reading interests and who
all focus on how they decided to become writers.
Writing for Publication. Although most MLIS students
do not prepare writing assignments with an eye towards
publication, some do prepare essays ultimately going
into print in a journal. Faculty members are always
on the lookout for essays with publishing potential,
and they are happy to provide advice. From time
to time, faculty members also will undertake joint publishing
projects with students.
There are guides for students to move from course projects
to publication. Walter W. Powell, Getting into
Print: The Decision-Making Process in Scholarly Publishing
(Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1985) provides
a useful book on the characteristics of scholarly history,
including its history, the nature of editorial work,
the selection processes in both scholarly journal and
book publishing, and the financial and administrative
aspects of academic book publishing. A lot has
happened in the twenty years since this book was published,
but it still offers a convenient benchmark analysis of
how the scholarly publishing industry works.
While not aimed at masters-level students, William Germano,
From Dissertation to Book (Chicago: University of Chicago
Press, 2005) is nevertheless a thorough introduction
to scholarly publishing. Since graduate schools and advisors
spend little energy in explaining what to do with a dissertation
once it is done, Germano wrote this book. He offers
advice on figuring out the marketplace, identifying what
a broader readership means and revising for it, working
with an editor and publisher, helping the beginning scholar
understand why the dissertation is not yet a book, determining
whether a dissertation should be expanded into a book,
the basic common weaknesses to revising dissertations
into books (audience, voice, structure. length), and
planning and carrying out the revision. Germano
offers this general advice and commentary about the nature
of scholarly writing and publishing: “Scholars
who write and publish are probably happier than those
who don’t. This is a completely impressionistic
take, I admit, and there are doubtless deeply depressed
academics who nonetheless publish furiously. But
like physical exercise, writing is the tiring thing that
gives you more energy after you’ve done it. Writing
is a risk, and risk is exciting, and excitement is something
you will fight to sustain in your professional life as
you age and your students don’t.” Also, “Writing
is a lifelong occupation, an avocation, a battle, and
in it we find out what we think and who we are. Learn
to practice the habit of writing. Set aside daily
writing time and make the lined pad or the desktop screen
your regular companion. Let it become your devotional
exercise, even if it is the only devotional practice
in your life. Your career as an employed scholar
depends on it, though I think the rewards – for
you, for the rest of us – are more important than
that. What you write is a part of who you are,
and in that sense every volume of your writing is a piece
of autobiography.” And, of course, this is not
bad advice for anyone taking on any kind of writing project.
Mentoring. Students in the MLIS program will have
the opportunity to work with faculty members who are
engaged in research and writing projects of many kinds,
from professional articles to research reports to scholarly
monographs. Students interested in gaining additional
experience in developing their writing skills will have
ample opportunities to work with faculty, and they should
not be shy in seeking advice and additional help. As
part of this, as they take various courses, students
should seek advice for additions to their professional
library of research and writing tools. There are
numerous manuals, for example, on research methods (historical,
anthropological, literary and cultural studies, behavioral,
etc.) applicable to the work of information professionals
that could be added to such libraries.
Conclusion. Learning to write is a life-long activity. Learning
how to conduct research in the library and information
professions starts with study in graduate programs such
as the one at our School. MLIS students should
pursue every opportunity they have to learn about the
art and science of researching and writing. If
nothing else, it is a lot of fun.
|
|